Ludwig Wittgenstein (26 April 1889 – 29 April 1951) was an
Austrian-British philosopher who worked primarily in logic, the philosophy of
mind, and the philosophy of language. From 1939–1947, Wittgenstein taught at
the University of Cambridge and Philosopher Bertrand Russell described him as
"the most perfect example I have ever known of genius as traditionally
conceived; passionate, profound, intense, and dominating.”
The film directed by Derek Jarman provided an insightful
portrayal of his life and story. We felt that the acting gave a realistic
representation of how Wittgenstein would have discovered his ideas and theory,
and showed the true human nature of his discoveries. Throughout the play it
shows how his philosophical work had affected his various relationships which
we feel shows a different aspect to his character and allows the audience to
see how his work was perceived by many around him. It also realistically showed
that Wittgenstein would have faced struggles and criticism in his work, even
from those he valued as friends allowing the audience to see how he would have
been constantly trying to justify his ideas.
However the play also had some negative aspects as we feel
that it was very focused on his psychological state, which is portrayed as
unstable at points, rather than his philosophical ideas and theories. This
distracts from the essential points that he is trying to make which can make
Wittgenstein seem less significant. Another choice by Jarman was to portray
Wittgenstein’s character as erratic where this may not have been completely
true and for many this may influence their view of Wittgenstein.
Overall the style of the play can seem rather distracting
from the character of Wittgenstein, but the portrayal of the events of his life
and his story provides an accurate account of Wittgenstein’s life.
Emma and Ella
I think you are right about it needed to show more of his philosophical theories - but maybe we are a biased audience!
ReplyDeleteRegardless, I agree with your conclusions. A good review - thanks for sharing!